YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts
How to Craft a Cravable Offer That Grows Your Cheer Gym
Dan Cotton, known throughout the industry as the pricing guy in cheerleading, argues that your offer matters even more than your price. In this solo episode, he breaks down four proven offer enhancers that make families feel silly saying no.
Why Your Offer Beats Your Price
Welcome to another episode of the Cheer Biz Podcast. In this episode, host Dan Cotton flies solo to tackle a topic he believes is even more important than pricing, which is saying something coming from the man widely known as the pricing guy in cheerleading. The subject is the offer: how to craft something so compelling that people feel foolish saying no, and what gym owners can do to build the best possible offer inside their own programs.
Before diving in, Dan encouraged listeners to join the Cheer Gym Owners and All-Star Cheer Coaches and Owners groups on Facebook. He also highlighted the AI Cheer Gym Owners Lab on Skool, a $37-per-month community where he and Danielle share the exact AI tools and techniques they use in their own gym to save time and money. As Dan put it, they are sharing material that other companies charge far more for, with an open-book approach. For gym owners who feel their business is not where it could be, or who are not even sure they have an offer, he pointed to the Cheer Biz Accelerator events, which combine classroom sessions on marketing, offer building, sales, and pricing with a hands-on deep dive into each attendee’s gym. Interested owners can visit nextgenowners.com and book a call to see if they qualify.
Dan opened the core discussion by naming a common mistake. Many gym owners figure out their price, often after hearing Dan say to charge what they are worth, and then simply present that price as a take-it-or-leave-it proposition. They never build a true offer around it. The assumption is that cheerleading is just cheerleading and there is nothing to dress up. But Dan pointed out that nearly every business sells a single core product. A car company is ultimately selling a vehicle, yet it still layers in elements that make buyers feel they need to act now. With Black Friday approaching, he said, this is the perfect moment for gym owners to rethink their offers. The goal is not to invent a new product but to make an existing one so cravable that families feel they must take advantage of it.
Dan noted that building value is one of the most powerful ways to strengthen an offer, and he promised a full future episode on that subject. This episode, however, focuses on offer enhancers: the specific levers that make an offer just a little bit sweeter.
Enhancer One: Limited Quantity
The first enhancer is limited quantity. When only a small number of something is available, it becomes more desirable because only so many people can get it. Low supply generally signals high demand. One easy way to put this into practice is by marketing waitlisted classes.
Some gym owners might object that their classes could absorb hundreds more kids, so there is nothing limited about them. Dan countered that every cheer gym has a finite number of spaces. There may be a limited number of classes on a given day, or a particularly popular class, such as a back handspring class with only two spots left. Those situations can be marketed honestly as limited availability.
He did include an important caution. Gym owners should not artificially create scarcity. Claiming something is almost sold out when it is not can leave a bad taste with families and, in some cases, may even be illegal. The scarcity needs to be real.
To illustrate, Dan shared an example from DreamCamps, his individual overnight camps. Individual campers can register for camp alone or choose a package: silver includes two private lessons and gold includes four. After running those tiers for many years, Dan added a platinum package. It includes no additional private lessons and no extra perks except one: the ability to sign up for private lessons first, giving those campers first pick of all the instructors. Only six platinum packages are available for every 50 campers. Despite offering nothing more than priority access, the platinum package sells out first every single time, and Dan can charge significantly more for it. Part of that success comes from limited quantity, and part comes from status, which he returned to later in the episode.
Enhancer Two: Limited Time
The second enhancer is limited time, and Dan said Black Friday makes this the ideal season to use it. A gym might offer birthday parties at 20 percent off from Black Friday through Cyber Monday, giving families just a few days to buy. That window creates a genuine sense of urgency. Families think that if they do not act now, they will miss out, and that feeling drives sales.
Dan stressed that the urgency should be real. Families should not just feel that time is limited; the window to take advantage of the offer should actually close. A limited-time offer also does not need to involve a discount. A gym could run a specialty class, camp, or clinic with a defined registration window, making it clear that once registration closes on a certain date, the opportunity is gone. There are many ways to work a limited-time element into an offer.
Enhancer Three: Smart Bonuses
The third enhancer is bonuses, the classic buy-this-get-that approach. Examples include buying a month of tumbling and receiving a free private lesson, buying a month of tumbling and receiving a t-shirt, or buying a package of four private lessons and getting the fifth free. Another option is booking a birthday party and receiving a month of tumbling at 50 percent off.
Dan’s guiding principle for bonuses is that they should hold real value for the customer while not costing the gym a lot of money. With a bit of humor, he pointed out that a gym could technically offer a free season of all-star cheerleading to anyone who enrolls in a month of tumbling. People would certainly buy it, but the gym would take a significant loss. Bonuses need to be strategic and should never cost more than the sale is worth.
He raised this point because he has seen gym owners make exactly this mistake. Dan recently spoke with a gym owner who raised all-star tuition and felt compelled to soften the increase by adding unlimited tumbling classes as a bonus. The math did not work. If an athlete took even one class, the family was effectively getting a discount compared to before the price increase, and if they took two classes, the gap only grew. The bonus and the price change were out of balance. The lesson is to be thoughtful, but when a gym can find a good bonus to include, it absolutely should, because it makes the offer stronger.
Enhancer Four: Guarantees That Remove Risk
The final enhancer is the guarantee. Guarantees make everyone feel more comfortable, and Dan said gym owners can absolutely put a guarantee on tumbling classes. Many already do and market it upfront: families will love their classes or get their money back. The gym sets reasonable parameters, such as requiring cancellation within the first two weeks to receive a full refund.
In practice, very few people ever take advantage of it. Dan observed that many gym owners who have run guarantees for years have issued only two to four refunds in total. There are a few reasons. Most families do not quit within the first two weeks. If a gym believes in its product, it can be confident customers will be happy. And even when a family does leave, most never ask for their money back or even remember the guarantee existed.
From the customer’s perspective, however, a money-back guarantee removes nearly all risk. Dan described it as essentially a two-week free trial that families prepay for, and if they do not like it, it costs them nothing. Any guarantee a gym can genuinely stand behind is a powerful way to enhance an offer.
Stack Enhancers for Maximum Impact
Dan urged listeners not to pick just one enhancer. Instead, gym owners should see how many they can stack into a single offer. If someone is even moderately interested in a product, there are only a few spots available, the purchase window is short, bonuses are included, and satisfaction is guaranteed, there is very little reason not to buy. The combination creates real urgency and a strong desire to purchase.
He acknowledged with a laugh that there are a few people like him who will almost avoid a buy-one-get-one-free deal on principle because they do not like taking things for free. But those people are few and far between. Most customers love these kinds of offers.
A Preview on Status and Value
Before wrapping up, Dan circled back to status. He clarified that building prestige into a product is not technically an offer enhancer but rather a preview of his upcoming episode on value. Still, status is something people value, and anything a gym does to make its product feel more premium enhances both the offer and the customer experience, making it easier to sell.
Returning to the DreamCamps platinum package, Dan explained that families buy it because they want the best. Even in today’s economy, there is a group of customers who would rather pay more for a top-tier experience than pay a little less and risk receiving lesser service. Creating packages that clearly market that top-tier experience can be incredibly valuable when crafting an offer.
Putting It All Into Practice
Dan closed by thanking listeners for their time and encouraging them to put these enhancers to work to strengthen their offers and grow revenue in their gyms. With Black Friday around the corner, there may be no better time to test limited quantity, limited time, smart bonuses, and confident guarantees. Be sure to join the Cheer Gym Owners and All-Star Cheer Coaches and Owners Facebook groups to keep the conversation going, check out the AI Cheer Gym Owners Lab on Skool, and visit nextgenowners.com to learn more about the Cheer Biz Accelerator events. Stay tuned for Dan’s upcoming episode on building value.
If you enjoyed this episode, you may also like “Why I Don’t Care What My Competitors Are Charging”
YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts


